The Financial Services Agency scheduled the first meeting of a new expert panel on Japan's equity market structure for 13 November, from 10:00 to noon, in person and online. The agenda lists a secretariat briefing, a presentation by a Nomura research institute, then discussion. The agency's note says the presentation reflects that company's views, not the FSA's.
The questions on the table
The secretariat's briefing paper asks how Japan's market structure should evolve, given blockchain and other digital technology and developments abroad, while keeping competition between venues compatible with fairness and transparency. It names three issues for private trading systems (PTS): the volume criteria applied to them, tick sizes at exchanges and PTS, and the market rules for PTS with a meaningful share of trading. It also asks whether dark pools, where trading is increasing, need institutional action on their regulation and transparency.
The secretariat traced the review to the government's growth-investment financial strategy of 21 July 2026, which committed to begin examining market structure within fiscal 2026 because trading in PTS is rising.
The numbers behind the review
By trading value in September 2026, exchanges handled 66.1% of listed-share trading, PTS 18.6%, dark pools 4.1% and other off-exchange trading 11.2%. The secretariat's PTS chart also labels 21.4% for August. Dark-pool trading value is on an upward trend.
The secretariat shows overseas comparisons, but cautions that they cannot be set simply against Japan's shares, because the data and venue categories differ. In the United States, off-exchange trading was 47.7% of value in September on Cboe data.
Where the rules sit now
The three PTS that handle listed shares all use customer-order matching for pricing. The auction method, which allows market orders and call auctions, is subject to ratio criteria against exchange trading: its trading must stay at or below 10% across all issues and at or below 20% per issue.
Dark pools sit under lighter rules. They need only a Type I financial instruments business registration, with minimum capital of ¥50mn, against ¥300mn for a PTS and ¥1bn for an exchange. They have no price-publication requirement. Orders matched in them are generally routed to the Tokyo Stock Exchange's off-auction market, and since 2020 participants must flag those orders.
The overseas backdrop
The Nomura presentation framed the debate around US and European fragmentation. It put off-exchange trading at 50.6% of US share volume in 2025. It also cited a June 2026 proposal to scrap the Regulation NMS order-protection rule, 23-hour trading at several US venues from 6 December 2026, and an EU cap on dark trading of 7% of 12-month volume, in force since October 2025.
The agenda gives no timetable for the panel's work beyond the first meeting.
