The Securities and Exchange Surveillance Commission (SESC) on 18 November recommended that the prime minister and the Financial Services Agency commissioner take administrative action against a Tokyo investment adviser. The recommendation follows an inspection by the Kanto Local Finance Bureau. It is a recommendation, not an imposed sanction.
The adviser is based in Chiyoda Ward, has ¥9mn in capital and 11 full-time staff. It recruited clients who had registered for free membership through internet advertising, then pitched advisory contracts by phone or email, using a sales approach designed to move them from a campaign plan to a weekly-advice term plan.
What the SESC found
Its pre-contract documents said fees would follow a target return set from a simulation of preset trading rules. Since 28 April 2023, the SESC says, the firm set no such target on 2,674 campaign contracts, which carried total fees of ¥549mn. The commission found the same stock offered on the same day under courses with different fees, across 23 stocks and 43 days. The ¥549mn is fees charged, not a measure of client losses.
The SESC also found three other practices:
- Salespeople used an invented department head, described as having strong stock-picking skills and networks.
- From 1 April 2023 to 22 September 2025, solicitation materials for the term plans carried data and graphs purporting to show how assets would change if clients switched to each week's recommended stocks. The SESC said they had no objective basis.
- Clients were told AI was routinely used in advice, though its use was limited.
Management failings
The SESC said the firm's representative, its only director, had no real involvement in management and left fund control to a shareholder. It also said he left compliance to the compliance head, who had told him the workload was excessive, and that the firm's documents named him as the only investment decision-maker although he was aware several salespeople picked stocks. It concluded the firm lacks staff with sufficient knowledge and experience.
Under Article 52 of the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act, the prime minister can revoke registration or order a full or partial business suspension of up to six months. The release does not say which step is proposed.
