Skip to content
Tokyo Brief東 京 ブ リ ー フJapan's day, wrapped and delivered by morning.

Policy

Policy Watch

Business lobbies want annual securities reports pruned, but analysts resist outright deletions

Keidanren and the Kansai Economic Federation want standalone accounts and duplicated items trimmed from securities reports and company histories cut back, while the analysts' association says its study groups found no item to delete outright, ahead of the FSA working group's November 18 meeting.

By Tokyo Brief DeskNov 17, 2026, 19:17 JST3 min read
Loose report sheets being sorted from several binders into a tray, with a few linked by cords to one master binder.

The Financial Services Agency's Disclosure Working Group meets on November 18 for its seventh session, with Keidanren, the Kansai Economic Federation and the Japan Securities Analysts Association each presenting on what belongs in the annual securities report, the statutory report listed companies file under the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act. The papers are stakeholder positions. None is FSA policy, and none records a conclusion of the meeting.

What companies want removed

Keidanren's paper of company comments names items it says are of little need in the securities report. They include standalone financial statements, company history, basic employee statistics such as average tenure and age, and a breakdown of parent-only data for consolidated groups. It also asks for a fundamental review of the "specified subsidiary" system, which it says duplicates similar subsidiary disclosures in other filings. One company in the paper says its standalone results are about a tenth of consolidated results, so detailed standalone notes add little.

The same paper cites a June 2025 Keidanren survey on filing before shareholder meetings: only 2 of 129 companies said they had received mostly positive investor feedback, and about 88% said investors had not reacted in particular. These are companies' own reports of investor response. The paper also objects to postponing shareholder meetings merely to make a securities report "pre-meeting", calling that a means turned into an end.

In its principles, Keidanren proposes sorting disclosure by true importance, timing and medium, and reusing one source of information rather than copying it between documents.

Three papers ahead of the November 18 meeting
Stakeholder positions as stated in each paper; none is FSA policy.
GroupBasisMain position
KeidanrenCompany comments; cites a June 2025 survey of 129 companiesCut duplicated and low-use items; reuse one source; do not delay shareholder meetings to file early
Kansai Economic FederationSurvey June 25 to July 22, 2026; 80 companies, 94 responsesDrop share-price highs and lows and total shareholder return; shorten history; allow standalone statements to be omitted
Japan Securities Analysts AssociationSurvey September 1 to 16, 2026; 24 of 24 members respondedNo item all groups agreed to delete; simplification and referencing acceptable if conditions met

Kansai's line-by-line list

The Kansai Economic Federation surveyed members from June 25 to July 22, 2026 and received 94 responses from 80 companies, about 23% of the roughly 350 members that file securities reports. It says the survey captures companies' sense of use and preparation burden, not investors' actual use.

Its proposals are specific. It would drop the highest and lowest share prices and total shareholder return from the key-indicator table, centre the company history on important changes and topics from roughly the last five years while leaving older detail to company websites, and let consolidated filers omit standalone statements by pointing to Companies Act accounts. It would also review the rule that policy-held shares be listed for up to 60 names, and the individual disclosure of pay at ¥100mn and above.

Analysts: no unanimous deletion

The analysts' association surveyed members of its three study groups from September 1 to 16, 2026. All 24 invited members responded. The association says the views do not represent all users of corporate reports. It reports that its groups could agree on no item whose entire entry should be deleted, and that many members asked for more company-specific writing instead.

Two items drew the most support for review. Seventeen of 24 saw room to change the disclosure of share subscription rights, mostly through simplification, and 16 of 24 saw room on management's discussion and analysis. Opinion on standalone financial statements split 10 to 10.

The analysts also say that references to other media should require simultaneous disclosure and legal backing. Investment-bank respondents warned that referencing other media could leave the scope of underwriters' responsibility for the referenced information unclear.